25 March 2009

It's time Gordon Brown stopped recycling other people's lines

I’ve warned Gordon Brown and his speechwriters before (HERE) that it’s not a good idea to lift lines from other people’s speeches. This was prompted by one of the lines from a speech he made in July last year:

“There’s nothing bad about Britain that cannot be corrected by what’s good about Britain …”

This bore an uncanny resemblance to something Bill Clinton had said in his inaugural address in January 1993:

“There is nothing wrong with America that cannot be cured by what is right with America.”

Then, when Brown spoke to the US Congress three weeks ago, he came up with:

“There is no old Europe, no new Europe, there is only your friend Europe.”

Not surprisingly, this got some commentators wondering if his scriptwriters had now started borrowing from the collected works of Barack Obama, whose address at the 2004 Democratic Convention had included the folowing:

“There is not a liberal America and a conservative America -- there is the United States of America. There is not a Black America and a White America and Latino America and Asian America -- there’s the United States of America.”

Obama subsequently recycled a similar version in other speeches, including the one in Chicago after he had won the election:

“We have never been just a collection of individuals or a collection of red states and blue states. We are and always will be the United States of America”

Recycling your own material may be acceptable, but there is nothing whatsoever to be gained from recycling material that sounds as though it’s been lifted from someone else – other than the kind electoral disaster Joe Biden experienced when his unattributed use of lines from a Neil Kinnock speech brought his otherwise promising 1987 campaign for the Democratic nomination to an abrupt end.

But Brown and his speechwriters still don’t seem to get it. So, here we are, hardly three weeks since he told the US Congress:

“There is no old Europe, no new Europe, there is only your friend Europe”

we hear him telling the European Parliament:

“There is no old Europe, no new Europe, no east or west Europe. There is only one Europe – our home Europe.”

Pass the sick bag please ...

7 comments:

Plato said...

:) but it is the sincerest form of flattery.

curly15 said...

I guess his speech writers must include a good smattering of (ex) journalists, well versed in the use of the 'right click'

Scan said...

Max,

It isn't only his speeches.

The truly toe-curling book Courage: Eight Portraits, by the lunatic Brown (or his ghost writer), explored the lives of eight outstanding twentieth-century figures. It sounds very much like the book Profiles in Courage, describing acts of bravery and integrity by eight United States Senators from throughout the Senate's history. The author? None other than John F. Kennedy.

Thatsnews said...

This is because Brown has no ideas.

A clever person would say: "As your own Senator Whatsyername said only last month..."

However, Brown is not clever.

Anonymous said...

But of course Obama was just borrowing from Lyndon Johnson's "There is no Negro problem. There is no southern problem. There is no northern problem. There is only an American problem."

Sal Pinto said...

But I guess politicians have been doing it since time immemorial.

Thatcher borrowed from St Francis.

Not just politicians either. The famous line "If I Had More Time I Would Write a Shorter Letter" was used by many including Mark Twain, Benjamin Franklin, Blaise Pascal, T S Eliot ... and the list goes on.

First recorded by Cicero, but he was not averse to a bit of plagiarism either.

Bhuvan Chand said...

Nice Article. Keep it up. But I think this is copy of your topic recycling process